Ethics & Law · single question

All of the following must be included in the informed consent discussion EXCEPT:

  1. Reasonable alternative treatments, including no treatment
  2. The itemized cost of the procedure
  3. The nature of the proposed treatment
  4. The material risks and potential complications
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: B. The itemized cost of the procedure

  • A. ALTERNATIVES, expressly including the option of NO TREATMENT and its consequences, must be presented. Omitting alternatives is among the most common consent failures.
  • B. CORRECT as the EXCEPTION. COST is a matter of financial disclosure and contract, not of INFORMED CONSENT. Consent doctrine concerns the patient's right to make an informed decision about a bodily intervention, and its required elements are clinical. Fee discussion is ethically and practically necessary — and belongs in a financial agreement — but its absence does not invalidate consent, whereas omitting a material risk does.
  • C. The NATURE of the proposed treatment — what will actually be done — is a foundational element of consent.
  • D. MATERIAL RISKS and complications are essential. A risk is 'material' if a reasonable person would want to know it when deciding.

Note: Mnemonic for consent elements — PARQ: Procedure, Alternatives, Risks, Questions. Add the patient's CAPACITY to decide and the VOLUNTARY nature of the decision. Document the discussion, not merely the signature.

Practice Ethics & Law questions Ethics & Law study notes

More Ethics & Law practice questions