Ethics & Law · single question

A patient in pain demands that healthy teeth be extracted; the dentist disagrees clinically. Which two ethical principles are most directly in tension?

  1. Justice and veracity
  2. Autonomy and beneficence
  3. Fidelity and justice
  4. Nonmaleficence and veracity
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: B. Autonomy and beneficence

  • A. Justice (fair allocation) and veracity (truth-telling) are not the central conflict here.
  • B. Correct. The patient's autonomy (right to choose) is weighed against beneficence (the dentist acting in the patient's best interest).
  • C. Fidelity and justice are not the principles primarily at odds in this scenario.
  • D. While nonmaleficence is relevant, the classic framing of this dilemma is autonomy vs. beneficence.

Practice Ethics & Law questions Ethics & Law study notes

More Ethics & Law practice questions