Periodontics · patient case question
At #19 the probing depth is 4 mm and the gingival margin lies 1 mm CORONAL to the CEJ. What is the clinical attachment level?
Patient case: Periodontal bone loss assessed on radiograph and at surgery
Patient: Female, 52 years old
Chief Complaint: “My gums have pulled back and my back teeth feel loose.”
Background: Irregular dental attendance. Former smoker. No relevant medical history.
Vital Signs: BP 126/78 mmHg · HR 74 bpm
Findings: Radiographs show angular loss of the crestal bone on the mesial of #30, the crest sloping apically away from the CEJ rather than running parallel to it. At #19, a periodontal probe calibrated in millimetres reads 4 mm in the sulcus, and the gingival margin sits 1 mm CORONAL to the CEJ. A surgical photograph after flap reflection shows an interproximal defect in which the bone is lost between two adjacent roots while the facial and lingual plates remain.
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: B. 3 mm
- A. 5 mm results from ADDING the 1 mm instead of subtracting it. Addition is correct only when there is true RECESSION, with the margin apical to the CEJ.
- B. CORRECT. CAL is measured from the CEJ to the base of the pocket. When the gingival margin is CORONAL to the CEJ — overgrowth or oedema rather than recession — that overlying distance is SUBTRACTED: CAL = probing depth − distance from CEJ to gingival margin = 4 − 1 = 3 mm. Recorded conventionally, a coronal margin is a NEGATIVE recession value, and CAL = PD + (−1) = 3 mm.
- C. 6 mm does not follow from any correct handling of these two numbers.
- D. 4 mm is the probing depth itself. Probing depth equals CAL only when the gingival margin sits exactly AT the CEJ, which is not the case here.
Note: Fix the sign convention and the arithmetic follows every time. CAL = probing depth + recession. Margin APICAL to the CEJ (recession) is a POSITIVE value and is added. Margin CORONAL to the CEJ (enlargement or oedema) is a NEGATIVE value and is subtracted. CAL, not probing depth, is what measures true destruction.