Ethics & Law · single question

An 80-year-old patient states that her oral health is excellent, but examination reveals extensive calculus and multiple carious lesions. What is the most appropriate response?

  1. Share your clinical findings and explore gaps in her understanding of her oral condition
  2. Refer her to a geriatrician for evaluation
  3. Proceed without comment, since the patient is autonomous
  4. Document the discrepancy and take no further action
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. Share your clinical findings and explore gaps in her understanding of her oral condition

  • A. CORRECT. There is a mismatch between the patient's PERCEPTION and the clinical REALITY. The appropriate step is patient EDUCATION: show her the findings — with a mirror, photographs, and radiographs — explain their significance in plain language, and identify what she does not know or has misunderstood. Informed autonomy requires accurate information first; a patient cannot make a meaningful choice about a condition she does not know she has.
  • B. A geriatric referral is appropriate if there are signs of cognitive impairment or systemic illness, but nothing here suggests that — over-optimistic self-assessment of oral health is extremely common at every age.
  • C. Autonomy does not mean silence. It presupposes that the patient has been given accurate information; proceeding without addressing untreated disease approaches supervised neglect.
  • D. Documentation alone does not discharge the duty to inform the patient and offer care.

Practice Ethics & Law questions Ethics & Law study notes

More Ethics & Law practice questions