Ethics & Law · single question

A patient with a known opioid use disorder presents wanting extensive restorative treatment. What is the MOST appropriate approach?

  1. Provide counselling and referral for the substance use disorder, then proceed with the dental treatment plan
  2. Provide emergency care only and permanently dismiss the patient from the practice
  3. Refuse all treatment until the patient completes a rehabilitation programme
  4. Proceed immediately with the full treatment plan and prescribe opioids as needed for pain
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. Provide counselling and referral for the substance use disorder, then proceed with the dental treatment plan

  • A. CORRECT. Substance use disorder is a chronic medical condition, and the dentist's obligation is the same as for any other comorbidity: acknowledge it, address it, and adapt the plan around it. That means a non-judgmental conversation, referral to appropriate treatment resources, a check of the state prescription drug monitoring programme, and a pain-management plan built on NSAIDs and acetaminophen with long-acting local anesthesia. Treatment then proceeds — the patient's oral disease does not pause while the addiction is treated.
  • B. Dismissing the patient after emergency care alone is discriminatory; substance use disorder is a recognised medical condition, not grounds for exclusion from a practice.
  • C. Refusing all care until rehabilitation is complete abandons a patient with active disease and is neither ethically nor clinically defensible. It also removes one of the few healthcare contacts many such patients still have.
  • D. Prescribing opioids to a patient with a known opioid use disorder without any modification of plan directly enables relapse and constitutes a failure of non-maleficence.

Note: Non-opioid analgesia is not a compromise here: the combination of ibuprofen with acetaminophen outperforms most opioid-containing combinations for acute dental pain, so the clinically superior choice is also the safer one for this patient.

Practice Ethics & Law questions Ethics & Law study notes

More Ethics & Law practice questions