Ethics & Law · single question
A patient with a history of opioid abuse demands a narcotic prescription. Clinical examination is within normal limits and you do not believe one is indicated. He refuses to leave until he receives it. What should you do?
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: A. Do not prescribe; if he refuses to leave and the situation escalates, contact security or law enforcement
- A. CORRECT. Two things must both be true. First, you do NOT prescribe a controlled substance that is not clinically indicated — that is illegal diversion regardless of pressure. Second, a patient refusing to leave the premises is a SAFETY and property matter: try de-escalation, offer alternatives (non-opioid analgesia, referral, addiction resources), and if he still will not leave, contact security or law enforcement. Document everything.
- B. A reduced quantity is still an unindicated controlled substance prescription. The problem is that no prescription is justified at all, not the amount.
- C. Prescribing under duress is both illegal and harmful to a patient with opioid use disorder. It also establishes the practice as a soft target.
- D. Referral is appropriate and should be offered — but it does not resolve the immediate situation of a patient refusing to leave, which still requires action.
Note: Practical protections: check the state prescription drug monitoring programme, adopt a written practice policy on controlled substances, and offer NSAID plus acetaminophen combinations, which outperform opioids for most dental pain.