Ethics & Law · single question
A patient who speaks limited English attends with her adult daughter, who offers to translate and mentions that her mother believes an evil spirit is causing her tooth pain. What is the BEST approach?
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: C. Use a trained professional medical interpreter, and acknowledge the patient's health beliefs respectfully
- A. An untrained bilingual staff member lacks medical vocabulary and interpreter ethics training, though this is preferable to a family member in an emergency.
- B. Confronting or correcting a cultural or spiritual belief damages trust and does not improve compliance. Acknowledge it, then explain the clinical findings.
- C. CORRECT. A TRAINED interpreter is the standard of care and is legally required for federally funded practices under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act. Family interpreters introduce errors, may filter or editorialize, cannot maintain neutrality, and compromise confidentiality — especially where sensitive information or a minor is involved. Culturally sensitive care also means acknowledging the patient's explanatory model without endorsing or dismissing it, then presenting the biomedical explanation alongside it.
- D. Family members are the classic source of interpretation error; children should never be used as interpreters.
Note: Phone and video interpreter services make this practical in almost any setting. Document that a professional interpreter was used.