Ethics & Law · single question

A 74-year-old male presents with his wife, who states 'He is here for his extractions.' The patient has hypertension, hyperlipidemia, a stroke 2 years ago, is wheelchair-bound, and his wife is the court-appointed legal guardian. Medications include lisinopril, atorvastatin, and warfarin. Non-restorable teeth #30 and #31 are planned for extraction. By using which principle of ethics can the patient's wife sign the consent form?

  1. Autonomy
  2. Beneficence
  3. Veracity
  4. Justice
Show answer and explanation

Correct answer: A. Autonomy

  • A. CORRECT. Autonomy is the ethical principle of self-determination and the right to make one's own decisions. Since this patient had a stroke 2 years ago and can no longer consent due to residual cognitive deficits, his wife (as court-appointed legal guardian) exercises substituted decision-making on his behalf, which is an extension of the autonomy principle — the guardian acts as the patient's autonomous agent to give informed consent.
  • B. INCORRECT. Beneficence is the principle of 'do good' — acting in the patient's best interest. While this principle guides the treatment plan, it does not specifically address the mechanism of who can legally sign the consent form.
  • C. INCORRECT. Veracity is the principle of truthfulness and honesty — being truthful with patients about diagnoses, risks, and alternatives. It does not address who may provide consent.
  • D. INCORRECT. Justice refers to fairness and equitable distribution of dental care and resources. It does not address the legal basis for surrogate decision-making.

Practice Ethics & Law questions Ethics & Law study notes

More Ethics & Law practice questions